How to Transition an Airbnb to a Long Term Rental in the Poconos
- Jeremiah Noll
- Nov 7, 2025
- 4 min read
Updated: Dec 29, 2025
TLDR: Transitioning from an Airbnb to a long term rental in the Poconos is a smart move if planned, not a step down. Focus on planning, right-sizing rent, updating setup, and screening thoroughly. Galvanized can make the entire process seamless so owners enjoy stability, consistency, and compliance with township and insurance rules.
Not every short-term rental stays short-term forever. Sometimes township rules change. Sometimes profits dip. Sometimes you just want less stress. Whatever the reason, if you are thinking about converting your Poconos STR to a long-term rental, the key is to do it with intention, not panic.
We have helped many owners make this switch the right way. Here are the things to consider before you list and the steps for a smooth, legal, and profitable transition.
Don’t Wait Until You’re Burned Out
Too many Airbnb owners come to us after hitting a wall with turnover, permit stress, or a slow season that did not recover. At that point, it becomes a reaction instead of a plan.
The best transitions happen when you still have choices. If your bookings are soft in winter or spring, use that lull to prep for a shift instead of letting the house sit empty.
Switch Your Setup
LTR guests need different systems than STR guests.
At a minimum, you should:
Remove or lock up high-end Airbnb extras like hot tubs, game consoles, or fragile decor. These rarely add enough value for LTRs to justify the hassle.
Consider selling off furniture and tech. Most long-term renters have plenty of their own items.
Notify utility companies which date tenants take over responsibility.
Remove smart home cameras and security alarms to protect tenant privacy.
Consider converting your game room back into a garage. Long-term tenants use the garage. Most do not care about a game room.
You are not marketing a getaway now. You are offering a home. That shift matters for rent, market, and tenant expectations.
Set a Market-Rational Rent Price
A high monthly Airbnb gross does not reflect LTR pricing. From our experience managing 175+ Poconos rentals, most STR-to-LTR homes rent for $1,100 to $2,400 a month, depending on location, size, and amenities. We run competitive comps and local occupancy data to recommend a number that actually fills the unit—not one that just sits on Zillow.
Prepare for Different Wear and Tear
A family renting for 12 months is not the same as guests coming for weekends.
You will have:
Less utility fluctuation.
Less appliance wear from frantic changeovers.
Fewer requests for small repairs.And you will enjoy:
Fewer turnovers.
Steady rent checks.
No midweek deep cleaning issues.
Lower rent is a trade-off many owners find easier to manage than constant headaches.
Choose the Right Lease and Tenant
Not every renter fits a former Airbnb. At Galvanized, we screen for income, credit, and rental history.
We:
Draft a legally compliant Pennsylvania lease.
Let owners review the applicant before placement (optional).
Handle key handoff, move-in logistics, and utility switchover.
Your unit only succeeds if you have the right lease and the right tenant.
Update Your Tax and Insurance Setup
Switching from STR to LTR often means you will need to update:
Your insurance policy. LTR coverage is usually cheaper.
Your business or tax classification. Deductions may change.
Local filings. You may no longer need an STR permit or separate license.
We will work with your accountant or insurance pro to document every change.
Jeremiah’s Take: This Isn’t a Step Down. It’s a Smart Shift.
Many owners think switching to LTR is a sign they failed at Airbnb. That simply is not true. We have seen plenty of owners move to long-term either because the math was better or township/policy headaches got too high.
With good prep, LTR brings more stability and usually less overall hassle. The right manager keeps you in the driver’s seat, it just means the chaos goes away.
Thinking About Making the Switch?
Galvanized offers full-service STR to LTR transitions for Monroe County owners. We handle everything from pricing and leasing to tenant screening and maintenance.
If you are ready to move beyond the weekly turnover game, contact us to talk about how to make the transition work for you. Note: Rental prices, township rules, and insurance requirements change frequently. Always verify current data with local realtors, compliance officers, and your insurance provider.
FAQ: STR-to-LTR Conversion in the Poconos
Is it hard to find good tenants in Monroe County?
Not if screening is thorough. Local demand is steady. The key is screening and pricing to the local market. We verify income, credit, evictions, and rental history so you are less likely to experience missed rent or damages.
Who handles utilities and snow removal in a long-term Pocono rental?
Typically, tenants cover electric, internet, propane, and sometimes gas. Owners usually pay water/sewer plus HOA fees (if applicable). Snow/lawn care is specified in your lease. We clarify all responsibilities upfront.
Should I sell or convert if my Airbnb isn’t performing?
If reviews are up and down, revenue is dropping, or township rules grew tougher, shifting to LTR can save your income and sanity. We help owners compare net ROI in both models and make the move when numbers favor long-term.
What does Galvanized do in an STR-to-LTR transition?
We handle the full transition:
Full property walk-through to prep for tenant use.
Pricing, tenant search, and lease drafting.
Maintenance setup and monthly rent collection.
Help with selling or storing surplus furniture, if needed.
From start to finish, we focus on reducing vacancy time and your transition on track.
About the Author
Jeremiah Noll is the founder of Galvanized Management, a fully licensed property management brokerage based in the Poconos. A former math teacher turned real estate investor, he built his company from firsthand experience managing rentals, flips, and township compliance. Today, Galvanized Management oversees more than 175 short-term and long-term rentals with a trusted in-house team. PA Broker RM425834.
Reviews & Testimonials
We manage short and long-term rentals across the Poconos and help owners protect ROI, stay compliant, and improve guest experience. Read more client testimonials.
“We are renters with Galvanized Property Management and have had a great experience. The team here is hardworking and integral. They take care of issues promptly as they arise. I would recommend renting and/or working with Galvanized!”
-Brittany Chesonis
“The Galvanized team is always there when you need them. There's no project to big or too small and they always call you back which is rare in the area! I'm glad I found them. A real gem.”
-Amanda Leigh
Comments